The Impact of Section 197 of the Planning and Building Law on Property Values
Introduction
The approval of building plans near residential properties or for alternative purposes can significantly affect the value of the properties. Section 197 of the Planning and Building Law allows property owners to seek compensation for the decrease in their property values resulting from the approval of such plans. This article will explore the eligibility criteria for compensation, the process of making a claim, the duration of the process, and alternative mechanisms offered by local authorities.
What Can You Do if a Building Plan is Approved Near Your Property?
In densely populated areas, the construction of more and more residential towers is a common occurrence. However, if a residential tower is approved to be built in front of your property, it can negatively impact your privacy, obstruct your view and natural light, increase density, and cause traffic congestion on your street. Moreover, it can also lead to a decrease in the value of your property.
Section 197 of the Planning and Building Law regulates compensation for the decrease in property values due to the approval of a building plan. The decrease in property value can be a direct result of the plan if it limits the use of the property, or an indirect result, such as the construction of a highway or interchange near your property causing noise pollution and obstructing the view.
It is important to note that the claim for compensation is related to the approval of the plan itself, such as the plan for the construction of the tower, and not the construction phase. Therefore, it is crucial to file the compensation claim before the construction of the tower is completed (i.e., after the plan is approved).
How Do You Know if a Plan Has Been Approved?
According to the law, the approval of a plan must be published in two daily newspapers, at least one of which is widely circulated. Additionally, a sign must be placed prominently in the area of the plan. If the plan affects one or more properties on a land area of up to 3 dunams (approximately 0.75 acres), a sign or notification must also be personally delivered or sent by registered mail to the owners and holders of rights in the adjacent properties.
The Three-Year Limitation Period
According to a recent ruling by the Supreme Court, the limitation period for filing a compensation claim under Section 197 of the Planning and Building Law begins from the effective date of the plan. This means that the claim must be filed within three years of the plan coming into effect, which is 15 days from the date of publication in the official records or newspaper.
The Supreme Court emphasized the importance of the three-year limitation period as a balance between the property owner's right to compensation and the public interest in allowing for efficient and effective planning without creating a chilling effect. Therefore, it is crucial to be aware of the time limitations and take prompt action if you believe your property value has been negatively affected.
Who is Eligible for Compensation?
To be eligible for compensation, the property owner must have owned the affected property or held rights to it on the effective date of the plan. The compensation can be claimed from the local planning and building committee, subject to the conditions specified in Section 200 of the law.
The Compensation Claim Process
The compensation claim should be submitted to the local planning and building committee within three years from the effective date of the plan. However, the Minister of the Interior has the authority to extend the time period for special reasons, even after the expiration of the original limitation period.
It is important to consult legal professionals experienced in property law to ensure that your compensation claim is properly prepared. They can assist in gathering relevant evidence, such as expert opinions on the decrease in property value caused by the plan's approval.
Alternative Compensation Mechanisms
While the use of Section 197 is relatively limited, local planning and building committees can offer alternative compensation mechanisms with different tax implications. In general, compensation received for property value decrease is not subject to capital gains tax since it does not involve the sale or transfer of the property. Therefore, it is advisable to seek tax advice before reporting the compensation transaction.
Conclusion
Section 197 of the Planning and Building Law provides property owners with a legal framework to seek compensation for the decrease in property values resulting from the approval of building plans. By understanding the eligibility criteria, the claim process, and the time limitations, property owners can protect their rights and seek fair compensation. It is essential to consult legal professionals and tax advisors to navigate the complexities of the compensation claim process and ensure the best possible outcome.
For more information and consultation, please contact our office.
